KBRA Affirms Ratings for First Interstate BancSystem, Inc.
19 Nov 2026 | New York
KBRA affirms the senior unsecured debt rating of BBB+, the subordinated debt rating of BBB, and the short-term debt rating of K2 for Billings, Montana-based First Interstate BancSystem, Inc. (NASDAQ: FIBK) ("the company”). In addition, KBRA affirms the deposit and senior unsecured debt ratings of A-, the subordinated debt rating of BBB+, and the short-term deposit and debt ratings of K2 for the bank subsidiary, First Interstate Bank. The Outlook for all long-term ratings is Stable.
Key Credit Considerations
FIBK’s ratings are supported by its strong core deposit franchise, conservative balance sheet construction, robust regulatory capital levels, and historically favorable credit performance. The ratings further reflect an experienced management team that has made demonstrable progress repositioning the balance sheet, strengthening credit administration, and improving the company’s operating model. These strengths are partly offset by comparatively weaker recent-period profitability and NPAs that remain somewhat elevated relative to peers.
Operating performance has gradually improved following several years of below-peer profitability, supported primarily by NIM expansion and lower funding costs. Core ROA approached ~1.1% in 9M26, while NIM has expanded for ten consecutive quarters to 3.57% in 3Q26. Looking ahead, approximately $3.3 billion of earning assets with below-market yields are expected to reprice or generate cash flows through 2027, providing meaningful earnings tailwinds. However, continued noncore loan runoff, a securities-heavy earning asset mix, and modest balance sheet growth could constrain NII expansion and a sustained return to peer-level returns.
FIBK maintains a conservative credit philosophy and underwriting standards, serving the company well during periods of economic stress. Following the acquisition of Great Western Bancorp, Inc. (GWB) in 2022, however, FIBK encountered some negative credit migration which has been largely attributable to idiosyncratic issues arising from the acquired loan portfolio. That said, the credit profile appears to have stabilized and asset quality metrics have generally improved through 9M26, supported by proactive credit administration and continued portfolio de-risking. Criticized loans declined ~19% YoY to 6.7% of loans at 3Q26, although NPAs remained somewhat elevated at ~1.1% of loans.
Management’s strategic focus on core operations/markets and de-risking the balance sheet has boosted capital ratios, which have fueled a more aggressive share buyback program in 2025 and 2026. Regulatory capital levels are robust, with CET1 reaching 14.4% in 3Q26. While shareholder returns have increased, including $347 million of share repurchases since 2025, capital ratios remain comfortably above rated-peer levels. KBRA continues to view overall capital levels as appropriate for FIBK’s risk profile, while acknowledging that core capital ratios may converge with peer averages over the intermediate term as excess capital is deployed through shareholder returns and eventual organic growth. Further, we note that tangible common equity remains relatively low due to unrealized losses within FIBK's investment portfolio.
FIBK's funding and liquidity profile remains a key credit strength, supported by a granular, geographically diversified, and comparatively low-cost core deposit franchise. The strong deposit base drives total deposit costs that average 60-80 bps below peers and contributes to a 95% core deposit to total funding source ratio at 3Q26. Further balance sheet contraction and diminishing wholesale funding have contributed to a conservative 65% loan-to-deposit ratio, providing substantial funding flexibility. Together with ~$10 billion of contingent borrowing capacity and a sizable investment securities portfolio, KBRA views FIBK's liquidity position as strong and well positioned to support future relationship-based growth.
Rating Sensitivities
Positive rating momentum could be supported by sustained improvement in core profitability toward levels consistent with higher-rated peers, while maintaining strong asset quality and conservative capital management. Conversely, material deterioration in asset quality resulting in significant credit losses, a meaningful increase in risk appetite, weakening liquidity, or more aggressive capital management that erodes capital buffers could result in negative rating pressure.
To access ratings and relevant documents, click here.