KBRA Affirms Ratings for Oregon Mutual Insurance Company and Revises Outlook to Stable from Negative
20 Nov 2026 | New York
KBRA affirms the BBB- Insurance Financial Strength Ratings (IFSR) for Oregon Mutual Insurance Company (OM), and its wholly-owned subsidiary, Western Protectors Insurance Company (WesPro). The Outlook for both ratings has been revised to Stable from Negative.
The change in Outlook to Stable from Negative reflects the meaningful improvement in OM's underwriting and overall operating performance during the first nine months of 2026, following several years of significant underwriting losses and deterioration in risk-adjusted capitalization. The improvement has been supported by management's corrective underwriting actions, enhanced claims management, and operating efficiencies associated with the transition to MGT Insurance's operating platform in July 2025. OM reported a combined ratio of 96.9% and net income of $1.3 million through September 30, 2026, compared with a combined ratio of 137.0% and a net loss of $12.8 million in the comparable prior-year period. Additionally, policyholders' surplus increased to $47.1 million from $42.6 million at year-end 2025, while prior-year loss reserve development improved significantly. Although the sustainability of these improvements has yet to be demonstrated over a longer period, KBRA believes the progress in executing OM's revised business strategy has reduced the risk of further deterioration in its credit profile.
The ratings reflect OM's sound reinsurance program, conservative investment portfolio, and strong, long-tenured distribution relationships. OM maintains a comprehensive catastrophe reinsurance program that provides meaningful protection against significant catastrophe events, including wildfires, winter freezes, and earthquakes. The company's investment portfolio consists predominantly of high-quality fixed income securities and cash, with an average bond portfolio credit rating of AA- as of September 30, 2026. The ratings also benefit from OM's established regional market presence and long-standing independent agency relationships which have helped support policyholder retention and stabilize the company's market position amid significant changes to its business model. The strategic partnership with MGT has also supported improved operating efficiency and enhanced underwriting, claims management, and technology capabilities, contributing to reduced expenses, better use of data, and the recent improvement in operating results that have occurred over the 15-month period of the relationship.
Balancing these strengths are OM's modest risk-adjusted capitalization, prolonged history of unfavorable underwriting performance, significant adverse prior-year loss reserve development, and exposure to natural catastrophe event risk. OM's risk-adjusted capitalization has weakened materially in recent years, with its RBC ratio declining to approximately 283% at year-end 2025 from 511% at year-end 2021. The company also reported cumulative net underwriting losses of $72.3 million from 2021 through 2025, reflecting poor personal and commercial lines performance and significant adverse reserve development. Despite recent improvements, a sustained track record of underwriting profitability, favorable reserve development, and internal capital generation has yet to be demonstrated. Additionally, OM's exposure to wildfires, earthquakes, and other severe weather events necessitates meaningful reliance on reinsurance, leaving results susceptible to catastrophe volatility and potential changes in reinsurance availability and pricing. OM's reliance on MGT for a broad range of core operating functions introduces a degree of operational concentration risk, notwithstanding the successful implementation and demonstrated benefits of the integrated operating model. While the agreements provide contractual stability, a potential disruption or termination of the relationship could present operational challenges.
Factors that could positively impact the rating include sustained underwriting profitability and internal capital generation resulting in materially stronger risk-adjusted capitalization and demonstrated improvement in the company’s risk profile, including reduced earnings volatility and reserve uncertainty. Factors that could negatively impact the rating include a material decline in risk-adjusted capitalization or operating performance, including significant catastrophe losses or continued adverse prior-year loss reserve development, failure to maintain an effective reinsurance program, termination of the MGA and/or fronting agreement with MGT without suitable replacement, or significant deterioration in the company’s risk profile or inability to successfully execute its operating strategy.
To access ratings and relevant documents, click here.
Click here to view the report.